Are Black Kids Being Missed in Dyslexia Screenings?

Black kids may be missed in dyslexia screenings. Learn what parents should ask schools and how to get reading support early.

Are Black Kids Being Missed in Dyslexia Screenings?
Black child reading a picture book during an early dyslexia screening activity.
Black child reading a picture book during an early dyslexia screening activity.
Source

Your child’s reading screener comes home marked “on track.” By spring, the teacher says your child “just needs to focus.” If those two messages don’t add up for you, you’re not imagining things.

Dyslexia screening is now part of school life in most of the country. That is real progress. But a screener is only as good as the test, the people reading the scores, and what the school does next. For Black children, each of those steps has a few weak spots worth knowing about.

What Are The Key Takeaways?

A screening result is a starting point, so treat it like one.

  • Ask for your child’s scores on each part of the screener, not only the overall label.
  • Check whether the screener measured sounds, word reading and spelling, or only reading speed.
  • Request extra reading support as soon as a risk flag shows up, without waiting for a diagnosis.
  • Write down what you see at home, from guessing at words to dodging homework.

Who Gets Into Dyslexia Reading Programs, And Who Doesn’t?

Dyslexia is common. Reading Rockets notes that as many as 15 to 20% of people have some of its symptoms, including slow or inaccurate reading and poor spelling. In a class of 25, that could mean four or five kids.

The real question is which of those kids the school notices.

One large study looked at 7,947 second graders in 126 schools in a state that screens students for dyslexia. Students of color were less likely to get a dyslexia classification. So were children in schools with a higher share of students of color.

The study found one more pattern. Kids who showed signs of dyslexia were more likely to go unclassified when many classmates had similar reading struggles. When a whole school is behind, a child with dyslexia can blend in. Her struggle starts to look normal for that building.

That label matters because it often opens the door to Structured Literacy, an approach that teaches sounds, letter patterns, syllables, and word parts one step at a time.

Voyager Sopris Learning builds its dyslexia reading programs on that approach, with options that run from phonics-based tutoring in the early grades to intervention for middle and high school students. Wilson Language Training and the Barton Reading and Spelling System are two other names many parents hear in IEP meetings. The details differ, but each one teaches reading directly and in sequence instead of hoping a child picks it up along the way.

A child who is never flagged never gets near that kind of help.

Can A Screener Mistake Dialect For A Reading Problem?

Many Black children grow up speaking African American English at home. It is a full dialect with its own rules. It is not “broken” English.

The trouble is that many reading and language tests are written and scored in General American English. Researchers at the Tennessee Center for the Study and Treatment of Dyslexia point out that children with more exposure to that variety are likely to score higher on those tests.

That can cut both ways. A child may be marked wrong for a pronunciation that is correct in her dialect. Or a real reading problem may get waved off as “just the way she talks.”

Julie Washington, a speech-language pathologist and professor at UC Irvine, has spent years on this question. Her research team followed 835 African American children in first through fifth grade to see how dialect and reading develop together. The findings suggest the two are linked, with reading and dialect use shaping each other over time.

The lesson for you is simple. A score is not the whole story. Ask who scored the screener and whether they know how to account for dialect.

Why Does A Missed Screening Cost So Much Time?

Reading problems rarely fix themselves. The longer a child goes without the right instruction, the wider the gap tends to get.

National numbers show how many kids are already behind. On the 2024 Nation’s Report Card, 40% of fourth graders scored below the basic reading level.

When that many children struggle, a school can start to treat low reading as normal. That is the same setting where the study above found dyslexia going unnoticed.

There is also a cost you won’t see on a report card. A child who can’t decode words often decides she isn’t smart. Some kids act out to avoid reading in front of classmates. Others go quiet. Either way, the behavior becomes the focus instead of the reading.

What Should You Ask The School After A Screening?

You don’t need to be an expert to ask good questions. Bring these to your next conference.

  • Which screener did you use, and what did it measure?
  • What were my child’s scores on each part, and how do they compare to the benchmark?
  • Did anyone account for dialect differences when scoring?
  • If my child is at risk, what reading support starts now, and how often?
  • How will you track progress, and when will we look at that data together?

Get the answers in writing when you can. A short email after the meeting that sums up what was said works well.

If the answers don’t sit right, you have backup. Nearly 100 parent training and information centers across the US and its territories help families with special education questions, at no cost. You can find the one for your state through the Parent Center Hub.

What Do Parents Often Ask?

Can I Ask For Another Look If My Child Already Passed A Screening?

Yes. A screener is a quick snapshot of one day. If what you see at home doesn’t match the result, tell the teacher in writing and ask what the next step is.

Should I Stop My Child From Using African American English?

No. Washington has long argued that teachers should value a child’s home language instead of suppressing it. Many classrooms now help kids notice when each way of speaking fits, so they can move between the two with confidence.

What Will You Look For On The Next Report?

A screener can open the door to help or quietly close it. Now that you know where kids slip through, which question will you ask first?