Tariffs and tipples

President Trump’s on-off tariffs on Scotch whisky call to mind an earlier tariffs tussle leading up to the Acts of Union The post Tariffs and tipples appeared first on Bylines Network.

Tariffs and tipples

The US Government officially lifted its tariffs on Scotch whisky on 24 July 2026, following a bilateral trade agreement. This removed the 10% levy that had been in place since April 2025 and cancelled a planned increase to 25% on single malts. American bourbon and whiskey casks now also enter the UK tariff-free.

An earlier tariff on a Scottish popular tipple

Almost exactly 50 years ago, I flew as a recent geology graduate to my first professional job in Australia. I flew on a Caledonian Airways flight, as a “ten pound Pom”. Along with one of the meals served was a card inscribed with the words:

“Proud and erect the Caledonian stood,
Prime was his mutton and his claret good.
‘Let him take port!’ The English statesman cried.
He took the poison and his spirit died.”

The exact authorship of these lines is uncertain; they are generally quoted as anonymous political doggerel written in response to the Methuen Treaty.

An early example of tariff policy was the Methuen Treaty of 1703 between England and Portugal, which favoured Portuguese wine over French claret by setting different import duties. Port gradually gained favour, and the Scots’ beloved claret suffered.

At that time, Scotland and England were entirely separate sovereign kingdoms that shared a monarch (Queen Anne) under the Union of the Crowns. The Parliament of Scotland operated independently in Edinburgh and set its own distinct trade laws, tariffs, and customs duties.

1703 was a year of intense economic tension between the two countries, leading Scotland to pass independent trade Acts including:

  • The Wine Act of 1703: While England was at war with France and banning French imports, the Scottish Parliament independently passed this law to allow the import of French wines into Scotland.
  • The Act for a New Imposition on English Commodities: Scotland retaliated against English trade restrictions by imposing heavy import tariffs (up to 80%) on English goods like cloth, hats and gloves.

The Methuen Treaty of 1703 had no direct impact on Scotland, as it was strictly a bilateral agreement between England and Portugal. However, it created an indirect economic disadvantage that pressured Scotland towards the 1707 Acts of Union.

The treaty allowed English woollen cloth to enter Portugal completely free of customs duties. Because Scotland was a separate nation, Scottish weavers and merchants did not receive this tax-free privilege. This put Scotland’s textile industry at a massive competitive disadvantage in Portuguese and European markets compared to their English equivalents.

By giving England exclusive commercial dominance over Portuguese trade, and access to Brazilian gold, the treaty demonstrated that Scotland’s economy was vulnerable and isolated.

The Alien Act of 1705 was also used by England to force Scotland into negotiations.

This separate authority over trade and import duties only ended with the Acts of Union in 1707, which dissolved the Scottish Parliament and created a single customs union with uniform duties across Great Britain.

Jug or flagon, claret has its role

I am not sure how claret stands today as a favoured Scottish tipple, but the elegant Claret Jug presented to the winner of golf’s Open Championship suggests that it is highly regarded.

My own relationship with a claret is not to be compared to that of the Caledonian, nor was it delivered in an elegant claret jug.

Mine came in a half-gallon flagon, perfect for wedging between a bed roll and the bulkhead in the back of a Land Rover. I’m told that the better clarets were not sold in flagons. The size was adequate for a lone site visit of a week or more in the hot, arid landscape of Western Australia. The red wine had one further advantage: I had no available refrigeration for the exploration work, and claret can be drunk warm.

A day’s work would begin at first light, and camp would be set up at dusk. I can confirm that a generous helping of claret, drunk from an enamelled tin mug by the campfire under broad, starry Antipodean skies, is a fine thing; I had no trouble sleeping. Tariffs, tipples, trade wars, trading blocs and alliances. We don’t seem to have made much progress in 323 years. There are still decisions to be made.

The post Tariffs and tipples appeared first on Bylines Network.