The back-to-school lines at Melchor are a referendum, and Belize keeps losing it

 By Horace Palacio:

Look closely at one number from last weekend, because it tells a whole national story.

On Saturday, our western border recorded 147 excursion passengers, the day-trippers who cross and return. On Sunday, that number exploded to 1,613. Eleven times higher in twenty four hours. That is not tourism. That is not family visits. That, my friends, is the great Belizean back-to-school shopping run, in a single statistic.

Ministry of Immigration data shows 4,903 passenger movements through the Western Border over August 15 and 16, up from 4,725 for the same weekend last year, a 3.8 percent increase. Behind those numbers stand Belizean mothers and fathers, lists in hand, crossing into Melchor de Mencos, Guatemala, for uniforms, undershirts, socks, shoes, and school supplies, ahead of the new academic year.

Now, before a single word more, let me say what must be said first.

Do not shame those families. Do not dare. That mother in the line is not disloyal to Belize. She is loyal to her children, exactly as she should be. She has done the arithmetic this column has begged Belizeans to do, counted her dollars twice, and gone where they stretch furthest. Her duty is to the three children she must dress by September, not to any merchant’s margin. If crossing a border saves her enough to buy the third pair of shoes, she is not the problem in this story.

She is the referendum. And Belize keeps losing it.

Run some honest, illustrative arithmetic. Suppose even half of those weekend crossings were shoppers, and suppose each spent a modest two hundred Belize dollars. That is roughly half a million dollars, in one weekend, at one border, before school even starts. Now add every other August weekend. Add the northern families making the same run to Chetumal. The true annual figure, nobody has counted. But every one of those dollars pays a Guatemalan shopkeeper’s rent, a Guatemalan worker’s wage, a Guatemalan government’s taxes, while the shops of San Ignacio, Benque, and Belize City watch their own customers drive past.

So the only question worth asking is the one nobody in authority seems to ask. Why is it cheaper to school-shop in another country?

The Guatemalan merchant is not a magician. He simply operates in a bigger market, closer to a real garment industry, Guatemala actually manufactures clothing, with cheaper wholesale channels and a lighter cost structure. Meanwhile, look at what a child’s uniform must survive to reach a Belizean shelf. An expensive port. Freight and fees. Import duty at the wharf. GST at 12.5 percent stacked on top of the duty-inflated price. And then the margins of a small, concentrated import trade this column has written about before, where thin competition lets prices rest fat. By the time that shirt hangs in a Belizean store, it wears more taxes and costs than the child will wear clothes. The mother is not fleeing Belizean merchants. She is fleeing the Belizean cost stack. Melchor did not win her. We drove her there.

Now, the wrong answer, and let us kill it before some official proposes it. The wrong answer is walls. Raise the exit fees, tighten the border, squeeze the shoppers back home. Understand what that does. It punishes the poorest families for the failure of the system, taxing the mother a second time for the crime of surviving the first tax. You do not keep customers by locking the shop door. You keep them by fixing the shop.

So here is how government fixes the shop. Seven policies, most executable before next August.

One. Zero-rate the school basket, permanently. Take GST off children’s uniforms, school shoes, exercise books, bags, and basic supplies. I made this exact recommendation in the minimum wage series, lighten the basket the poor actually buy. There is no basket more deserving than the one that dresses a child for school.

Two. Declare an annual back-to-school duty holiday. A two-week window each August when import duties on school essentials are suspended. Tax holidays for school shopping are a tested tool used across American states for decades. Give Belizean merchants two weeks each year to compete on level ground, and watch the lines move from Melchor to Albert Street.

Three. Sew the uniforms in Belize. A school uniform is one of the simplest garments made, and this country is full of skilled seamstresses and village sewing groups. Launch a national uniform initiative, duty-free fabric supplied to Belizean sewing cooperatives, and government-assisted schools directed to source Belizean-made uniforms, counting toward the twenty percent small-business procurement rule already promised under the new procurement law. Every uniform sewn here is a wage paid here.

Four. Bulk-buy like a nation. Belize already runs a textbook program that buys at scale. Extend the model. Let schools, PTAs, and credit unions pool orders for supplies at true wholesale prices, sold to parents at cost. The Guatemalan advantage is partly wholesale muscle. Four hundred thousand people buying separately have none. Organized, we have plenty.

Five. Attack the landed cost itself. Everything this column has said about the expensive port, slow customs, and the duty schedule lands directly on this school shirt. Review the duties on children’s essentials specifically. A country that taxes school clothes heavily should not act shocked when school shopping emigrates.

Six. Referee the margins. Where competition is thin, publish the numbers. Landed cost versus shelf price on staple school items, in the open, every August. Sunlight on margins does what a hundred press releases cannot. And it protects the honest merchant too, by proving who is fair.

Seven. Help the poorest through Belizean tills. Expand existing school assistance into a school-starter support for the neediest families, delivered as vouchers redeemable at Belizean merchants. The family gets the help. The dollar stays home. One policy, two victories.

And a word to our merchants, because government is only half of this. The border is your competition report card, delivered every August. Sharpen your sourcing. Pool your wholesale orders. Run your own back-to-school pricing like you mean to win the mother back. I wrote weeks ago that in this new economy, money moves from the waiting to the working. That applies on Albert Street too.

Here is the measure of success, plain and countable. Next August, the Ministry of Immigration will hand us this same weekend data. If the policies above are done, the excursion number shrinks, and the lines grow where they belong, outside Belizean shops, manned by Belizean workers, ringing Belizean tills.

The mothers are not waiting for speeches. They vote with their feet every August, in the most honest election this country holds.

Stop blaming the voters, Belize.

Win the vote.

The views expressed in this article are those of the author, Horace Palacio, and do not necessarily reflect the views or editorial stance of Breaking Belize News.

The post The back-to-school lines at Melchor are a referendum, and Belize keeps losing it appeared first on Belize News and Opinion on www.breakingbelizenews.com.